In my last post about Milwaukee, I wrote about places that were a little more high-end than the more casual eateries I mentioned last week. But before I do, let me mention one of my favorite TV shows for context. I’m a fan of the Bravo program “Top Chef,” a competition between a dozen-plus professional chefs, often held in one American city. I started watching when they produced it in Denver in 2017 (although they’ve been on the air since 2006), and I’ve seen nearly every season since.
Two years ago, “Top Chef” came to Milwaukee, and I probably wasn’t the only person who thought, “Why are they in Wisconsin?” Not many thought that the city, mostly known for those brats, beer and cheese I previously mentioned, was a culinary hub that could compete with its neighbor down the Lake Michigan shore, Chicago. While it’s smaller and will likely never grow as much as the Windy City, Milwaukee can certainly claim its share of gastronomic excellence, especially with the places we IFWTWA conference attendees visited.
I’m only mentioning three places here, two of which are part of the Bartalotta restaurant group. We were fortunate to have Chef Paul Bartalotta, who started the business with his late brother Joe and was a key featured guest on “Top Chef,” specially prepare a meal for us at High Stakes, which I’ll talk about first.
High Stakes
Not many restaurants have been inspired by a brocade pillow, but that’s what Chef Paul asked his designer to use for this restaurant, which is only a few months old. Richly adorned in burgundy wallpaper, white silk draping on the ceilings, red leather booths in its dining room, and an elegant cerulean light blue built-in for its bar (appropriately called the Peacock Lounge), it’s unlike any other steakhouse I’ve seen because of that small decorative element. But that’s not even the most delightful aspect about High Stakes.
That would, of course, be the food and drink we enjoyed, which were pre-selected from a special menu. This included herb-crusted filet mignon, with porcini mushroom bone marrow, wine sauce, potato mousseline and wilted spinach; pan-seared salmon, with squash and artichoke fricassee, rendered ham, sungold tomatoes and sauce vierge; and mushroom Parmigiano-Reggiano risotto. I think 90% of the group ordered the filet, while I chose the salmon. I did try one of my tablemate’s filets, which was an incredible melt-in-the-mouth treat. The meals were rounded out with either a pear salad or Caesar salad starter and a baba au rhum for dessert. Everything was simply exquisite, like a royal dinner made for us.
Harbor House
Another Bartalotta restaurant is this seafood eatery on Lake Michigan and close to Milwaukee’s showcase art museum. Unlike High Stakes, Harbor House feels more casual, like a New England seafood shack with its whitewashed interior, subtle nautical décor, and framed windows overlooking the water. But that more easygoing vibe doesn’t mean you won’t get a special dining experience. With a smaller group of friends, we could order directly from the menu and had more options.
Some of the entrees we chose included filet mignon (which probably wasn’t quite as tender as the one at High Stakes but was still excellent), miso-glazed salmon, whole branzino, steamed mussels in coconut lemongrass broth, and tuna tartare with wonton chips. I ordered a seasonal salad with burrata, delicata squash, cranberries, pepitas and arugula with a balsamic brown butter vinaigrette. It was a tasty mélange of sweet and savory, bursting with autumn flavors. Since I wasn’t that hungry, I had an appetizer-sized portion of crab cakes, which were both creamy and tangy with red bell pepper aioli, cabbage slaw and saffron-picked fennel. Later, we all shared two desserts: chocolate mousse and Boston cream pie.
Milwaukee Public Market
While this isn’t technically a restaurant, there are plenty of places to eat in this two-story, 21-year-old downtown market. USA Today readers have honored it as the best in the country for the last two years, and after seeing what it has to offer, I can see why. Nineteen different vendors primarily sell prepared and raw foods that look as fresh and vibrant as anything you’ll find at a farm. The builders modeled the market after Seattle’s Pike Place, but this one is more intimate and, therefore, more appealing.
Our group toured the market independently, which also gave us time to shop. I didn’t buy anything, and I regret it, but one of my friends purchased some gourmet chocolate bars and a pastry. Some things I thought about were cheeses, spices and baked goods. Should I return here in the future, I won’t make that same mistake. For our reception, we dined on grilled brats, noodle salad, German potato salad and empanadas, which was a small sampling of what the market offers. We also drank local beers, wines and cocktails, including the Wisconsin version of an old-fashioned (brandy instead of whiskey, plus soda).